US Crypto Strategic Reserve: Analyzing the Inclusion of Bitcoin and Altcoins
In a groundbreaking move on March 2, former US President Donald Trump revealed plans to incorporate Bitcoin, Ethereum, XRP, Solana, and Cardano into a newly established Crypto Strategic Reserve. This initiative aims to integrate these digital assets into America’s broader economic and financial strategies. The announcement sent immediate ripples through the cryptocurrency market, causing a surge in the prices of the mentioned digital currencies, fueled by both investor enthusiasm and speculative interest.
However, the decision to include a diverse range of altcoins alongside Bitcoin sparked a heated debate among financial experts and industry leaders. The discourse centered around the potential implications and long-term effects of such an inclusive approach.
The Bitcoin-Centric Perspective
Advertisement Banner
Notable criticism emerged swiftly, particularly from Jeff Park, the Head of Alpha Strategies at Bitwise. He described Trump’s decision as “a significant political miscalculation,” cautioning about the risks associated with the perception of insider dealings. Park emphasized Bitcoin’s unique status as the leading digital store of value, suggesting it warranted exclusive consideration. He warned that the inclusion of altcoins could lead to adverse political optics, especially given the uncertain regulatory and technological foundations of these newer assets.
Jeff Park’s Perspective
Park elaborated, “Trump’s political miscalculation lies in underestimating the importance of focusing solely on Bitcoin for the Strategic Reserve. Political opportunities are calculated by marginal gains of new votes versus the loss of existing ones. Elizabeth Warren’s anti-crypto stance made little sense, and Trump might soon realize what Bitcoin— and only Bitcoin—stands for in the crypto realm.”
He highlighted the potential for voter backlash, drawing parallels to past political missteps where courting new constituencies came at the cost of alienating established supporters. “The big issue here is optics. Including altcoins with uncertain national strategic significance may lead to assumptions of insider dealings, even if unfounded. This could have negative political repercussions, even among some crypto enthusiasts,” he added.
Hunter Horsley’s Viewpoint
Hunter Horsley, CEO of Bitwise, echoed Park’s sentiments. He expressed on social media platform X that he initially envisioned the Strategic Reserve focusing solely on Bitcoin, which he deemed the “undisputed store of value for the digital age.” While he acknowledged the administration’s openness to cryptocurrencies as a positive development, he argued that the term “reserve” implies stability and global recognition, attributes primarily associated with Bitcoin.
Horsley suggested that incorporating altcoins might undermine the fundamental principle of establishing a national reserve. “While many crypto assets have their merits, our discussion here is not about a US investment portfolio; it’s about a reserve, and BTC remains the definitive store of value for this era. I’m grateful the new administration is engaging constructively in this space and look forward to understanding their rationale,” he remarked.
Industry Leaders Weigh In
Other prominent figures in the cryptocurrency industry shared similar viewpoints. Brian Armstrong, CEO of Coinbase, proposed that “solely Bitcoin would likely be the optimal choice—simpler and a clear narrative as a successor to gold.” He also suggested an alternative: a market-cap-weighted index for broader cryptocurrency exposure. “If diversity is desired, a market cap-weighted index could provide an unbiased approach, but option #1 remains the simplest,” Armstrong stated.
Some approached Trump’s announcement from a philosophical angle. David Marcus, CEO and co-founder of Lightspark, bluntly stated, “Mixing the only code-driven asset with human-run ones is a mistake,” implying that Bitcoin’s decentralized, algorithmic approach to governance and supply is crucial for a genuine reserve asset.
Even long-time gold advocate and Bitcoin skeptic Peter Schiff offered a surprising partial endorsement of Bitcoin. “We have a gold reserve, and Bitcoin is digital gold. But what justifies an XRP reserve? What’s the purpose?” he questioned.
As of the latest data, Bitcoin’s price stands at $91,022.
