What Lies Ahead for Crypto Litigation? SEC and Binance’s Legal Pause Sparks Speculation
The recent announcement of a legal pause in the case between the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Binance has triggered discussions about the future of other cryptocurrency-related lawsuits. Some industry observers anticipate that this development could influence the trajectory of other ongoing cases, with Coinbase being a standout example due to its distinct circumstances.
Will Coinbase Follow in the Footsteps of the SEC vs. Binance Case?
In the wake of the SEC and Binance’s joint request to temporarily halt the lawsuit against the global cryptocurrency platform, there is widespread speculation within the crypto community about whether other similar litigations, including that of Coinbase, will follow suit. As previously covered by influential sources, the SEC and Binance have requested a 60-day suspension of their legal proceedings, citing potential implications of the SEC’s newly established Crypto Task Force, spearheaded by Commissioner Hester Peirce.
Advertisement Banner
This joint motion marks a significant moment, being the first of its kind since January 10, when Mark Uyeda took over as acting chair of the SEC. Observers anticipate that this could lead to similar pauses in non-fraud cases involving other major crypto entities such as Ripple, Coinbase, and Kraken.
However, as reported by journalist Elizabeth Terret, Coinbase finds itself in a particularly distinct situation. The exchange’s legal proceedings had already been paused last month, pending the SEC’s response to its appeal concerning the classification of crypto trades.
The SEC vs. Coinbase: A Unique Legal Battle
The SEC initiated legal action against Coinbase in 2023, accusing the exchange of operating as an unregistered broker-dealer and engaging in the unlawful sale of unregistered securities through its staking program. This case has now reached a critical junction after New York Federal Judge Katherine Failla permitted a “rare” interlocutory appeal. This decision was based on conflicting judgments from previous crypto cases and the necessity for clarity on applying the Howey Test to digital assets.
This appeal allows Coinbase to challenge the SEC’s claims at the Second Circuit Court of Appeals. On January 21, 2025, Coinbase submitted a petition for permission to appeal, urging the US appeals court to clarify that crypto trades are not securities. The exchange emphasized the urgent need for clarity on federal securities laws, highlighting that the SEC’s regulatory authority regarding secondary digital asset trades is a pressing issue.
The Crypto Sector Awaits the SEC’s Response by Valentine’s Day
The SEC’s deadline to respond to Coinbase’s appeal request is set for Friday, February 14. This response is highly anticipated, as it will likely provide insight into the regulatory agency’s approach to handling cryptocurrency-related litigation under its new acting chair and revised regulatory framework.
According to Terret, the SEC might choose to oppose Coinbase’s appeal request, which would suggest a continuation of the stance that most crypto tokens fall under securities laws, a view previously held by former chairman Gary Gensler. Alternatively, the SEC could refrain from opposing the request, signaling a willingness to address how securities laws apply to cryptocurrency under the guidance of the Crypto Task Force.
Another possibility is that the SEC might request an extension or decide to drop the case altogether. Terret concludes that the Commission’s forthcoming response to Coinbase will be telling of its strategy in dealing with ongoing litigation involving securities law disputes.
As the crypto industry eagerly anticipates this deadline, the outcomes could significantly impact the regulatory landscape and the future of cryptocurrency regulation in the United States.
